Your top 5 Cranks
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Your top 5 Cranks
Perch, Chub, Pike, no matter what is your top 5 Crankbaits ! Impossible in reality of course but it must be your favourite, hint ( your favourite) not the fishes choice, of course you want effective baits but sometimes other things override this decision !
Some baits you just love, if you have ever been for a bath and taken a “that” crank with you, you know what I mean !
Ok here are mine and it’s been hard to narrow down and in no particular order and with a highly trolling biased view here we go !
No 1- the Magna Strike 9” Grandma, discontinued since 97 but if you bought as many as me you ain’t running out any time soon !
No 2- 13” Magnum Shallow Invader, awesome big fish bait and a good hooker, cast or troll.
No 3- Bucher Magnum Shallow Raider, never had a fish under 13lb on this one and these have seen good few fish.
No 4- Floating or original Depth Raider, the (my) big fish statistics don’t back it up but there is something about it that it makes it on the list.
No 5- Tyrant Tackle’s 9” Shallow Czar whether cast or trolled it is one heck of a bait, solid foam + through wired.
In all honesty a top 5 is impossible but I would troll those on any body of water ignoring river systems where I would tend to go smaller. So what have you got ?
Some baits you just love, if you have ever been for a bath and taken a “that” crank with you, you know what I mean !
Ok here are mine and it’s been hard to narrow down and in no particular order and with a highly trolling biased view here we go !
No 1- the Magna Strike 9” Grandma, discontinued since 97 but if you bought as many as me you ain’t running out any time soon !
No 2- 13” Magnum Shallow Invader, awesome big fish bait and a good hooker, cast or troll.
No 3- Bucher Magnum Shallow Raider, never had a fish under 13lb on this one and these have seen good few fish.
No 4- Floating or original Depth Raider, the (my) big fish statistics don’t back it up but there is something about it that it makes it on the list.
No 5- Tyrant Tackle’s 9” Shallow Czar whether cast or trolled it is one heck of a bait, solid foam + through wired.
In all honesty a top 5 is impossible but I would troll those on any body of water ignoring river systems where I would tend to go smaller. So what have you got ?
- John Milford
- Ferox Trout
- Posts: 11027
- Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
- Location: Cloud Cuckoo Land
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
If you're trolling Steve, you're not using them as 'crank baits'. Are they any good for cranking?
Mine are:
Heddon Magnum Tadpolly
Heddon River Runt Spook
Mann's 1 Minus
Mann's Super Stretch 1 Minus
Halco Laser Pro 6"
Mine are:
Heddon Magnum Tadpolly
Heddon River Runt Spook
Mann's 1 Minus
Mann's Super Stretch 1 Minus
Halco Laser Pro 6"
"He's some sort of lure savant. Or just has an unhealthy addiction to old lures. We are not quite sure . . . . . "
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
John Milford wrote: ↑Wed Jun 12 2019 21:03 -They are Crankbaits John, even in the bath they are still Crankbaits ! 3 of those listed are technically flat sided Minnows, but you get the idea.If you're trolling Steve, you're not using them as 'crank baits'. Are they any good for cranking?
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
The Mann’s Super Stretch 1 Minus is a grand bait John, you can even take the rear hook off and add a size 4 Colorado blade and it makes a fantastic top water bait. Why am I talking top waters !
- Monts
- Ferox Trout
- Posts: 11312
- Joined: Tue Nov 17 2015 18:52
- Location: Yat Rock
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Chub Lure A Bomber Square A all day long.
Perch Lure MH Deep Diving Crank "n" Shad in Black Perch.
Perch again Cotton Cordell Grappler Shad in a Crawfish Pattern.
Pike MH Sniper, great action and a real fun lure to use.
Anything that swims a Manns 1-
Its what I always look for when sorting them out for a day along the river.
Perch Lure MH Deep Diving Crank "n" Shad in Black Perch.
Perch again Cotton Cordell Grappler Shad in a Crawfish Pattern.
Pike MH Sniper, great action and a real fun lure to use.
Anything that swims a Manns 1-
Its what I always look for when sorting them out for a day along the river.
If you wanna go fishing go fishing.- John Gierach
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Monts wrote: ↑Wed Jun 12 2019 21:23 -Chub Lure A Bomber Square A all day long.
Perch Lure MH Deep Diving Crank "n" Shad in Black Perch.
Perch again Cotton Cordell Grappler Shad in a Crawfish Pattern.
Pike MH Sniper, great action and a real fun lure to use.
Anything that swims A Manns 1-
Its what I always look for when sorting them out for a day along the river.
All alien to me I’m afraid, would I need to put my glasses on just to see them that’s the question
- Monts
- Ferox Trout
- Posts: 11312
- Joined: Tue Nov 17 2015 18:52
- Location: Yat Rock
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Steve Le maitre wrote: ↑Wed Jun 12 2019 21:29 -Monts wrote: ↑Wed Jun 12 2019 21:23 -Chub Lure A Bomber Square A all day long.
Perch Lure MH Deep Diving Crank "n" Shad in Black Perch.
Perch again Cotton Cordell Grappler Shad in a Crawfish Pattern.
Pike MH Sniper, great action and a real fun lure to use.
Anything that swims A Manns 1-
Its what I always look for when sorting them out for a day along the river.
All alien to me I’m afraid, would I need to put my glasses on just to see them that’s the question
If you wanna go fishing go fishing.- John Gierach
-
- Chub
- Posts: 1253
- Joined: Mon Sep 05 2011 05:00
- Location: Ireland
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Mostly trolling , and in no particular order except for an 8" Hooker , which is the first to be clipped on !
Salmo Perch SDR .
Musky Mania 8" Jake
Musky Mania 9" Ernie
Rozemeijer Tyson ,
There are a few more but you said 5 !
Pat .
Salmo Perch SDR .
Musky Mania 8" Jake
Musky Mania 9" Ernie
Rozemeijer Tyson ,
There are a few more but you said 5 !
Pat .
- John Milford
- Ferox Trout
- Posts: 11027
- Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
- Location: Cloud Cuckoo Land
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Steve Le maitre wrote: ↑Wed Jun 12 2019 21:18 -posting.php?mode=quote&f=48&p=556902The Mann’s Super Stretch 1 Minus is a grand bait John, you can even take the rear hook off and add a size 4 Colorado blade and it makes a fantastic top water bait. Why am I talking top waters !
"He's some sort of lure savant. Or just has an unhealthy addiction to old lures. We are not quite sure . . . . . "
-
- Zander
- Posts: 5602
- Joined: Mon Aug 29 2011 05:00
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
This changes like the wind depending on where I'm fishing, but 5 that I have total confidence in are:
1) Whopper Stopper Magnum Hellcat. Simple solid bodied slim 7" minnowbait that casts, twitches, and hooks very well.
2) Musky Mania Lil' Ernie. Catches everything including the big ones.
3) Legend Jnr. More subtle action that similar shaped baits. Indestructible solid body. Catches lots of fish on both depth settings.
4) Bradrock Molly Bait. Subtle actioned slim flat sided minnowbait. Fished fast the are awesome catchers. Solid body.
5) Hooker Tackle Jnr. Good big profile with an action that catches fish deep. Trolled deep and slow on leadcore they catch very well. Again a solid body.
Five is way too few to choose between. So especially for you Steve...
6) L&S Mirrolure 111MR. When depth raiders have blown (and they do because they catch so well) stick one of these on and go a bit faster.
1) Whopper Stopper Magnum Hellcat. Simple solid bodied slim 7" minnowbait that casts, twitches, and hooks very well.
2) Musky Mania Lil' Ernie. Catches everything including the big ones.
3) Legend Jnr. More subtle action that similar shaped baits. Indestructible solid body. Catches lots of fish on both depth settings.
4) Bradrock Molly Bait. Subtle actioned slim flat sided minnowbait. Fished fast the are awesome catchers. Solid body.
5) Hooker Tackle Jnr. Good big profile with an action that catches fish deep. Trolled deep and slow on leadcore they catch very well. Again a solid body.
Five is way too few to choose between. So especially for you Steve...
6) L&S Mirrolure 111MR. When depth raiders have blown (and they do because they catch so well) stick one of these on and go a bit faster.
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
royboy wrote: ↑Wed Jun 12 2019 22:14 -Mostly trolling , and in no particular order except for an 8" Hooker , which is the first to be clipped on !
Salmo Perch SDR .
Musky Mania 8" Jake
Musky Mania 9" Ernie
Rozemeijer Tyson ,
There are a few more but you said 5 !
Pat .
Very interesting Pat you placed the 8” Hooker on here and rate it so highly, more so is that you have the 8” Jake here ! - the 8” Jake !
Yes the Ernie is unique and pretty much bombproof, it’s also hard to get one snagged up solid - but top 5 ! What special things are you doing with it Pat ?
I still can’t get over the 8” Jake though
Thanks for those Pat, soon when we run out we can do another top 5
ps At the start I did say they could be your favourite and not necessarily “great” catchers so that explains the 8” Jake thing !
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
andrew_nagel wrote: ↑Wed Jun 12 2019 22:48 -This changes like the wind depending on where I'm fishing, but 5 that I have total confidence in are:
1) Whopper Stopper Magnum Hellcat. Simple solid bodied slim 7" minnowbait that casts, twitches, and hooks very well.
2) Musky Mania Lil' Ernie. Catches everything including the big ones.
3) Legend Jnr. More subtle action that similar shaped baits. Indestructible solid body. Catches lots of fish on both depth settings.
4) Bradrock Molly Bait. Subtle actioned slim flat sided minnowbait. Fished fast the are awesome catchers. Solid body.
5) Hooker Tackle Jnr. Good big profile with an action that catches fish deep. Trolled deep and slow on leadcore they catch very well. Again a solid body.
Five is way too few to choose between. So especially for you Steve...
6) L&S Mirrolure 111MR. When depth raiders have blown (and they do because they catch so well) stick one of these on and go a bit faster.
Andrew, a few questions Sir. With the Molly bait I’m assuming you are referring to the 7”, as you know they didn’t make either of these for long but if you are referring to the 9” you have a lot of explaining to do !
The Lil’ Ernie I get, if only the Ernie had the same sweet action, Pat likes them though !
I have one Magnum Hellcat - only one ! Yes no other 7” Minnow comes close.
Thanks for those Andrew. Oh you mention the Depth Raider, with 115 of the things I could find this hard to say but give me a 9” Triple D any day. I don’t own a single Mirrolure, maybe I should.
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Monts wrote: ↑Wed Jun 12 2019 21:23 -Sorry Jason I can’t comment on any of yours simply because of the sizes ! I know you like your Cranks so they all must be good.Chub Lure A Bomber Square A all day long.
Perch Lure MH Deep Diving Crank "n" Shad in Black Perch.
Perch again Cotton Cordell Grappler Shad in a Crawfish Pattern.
Pike MH Sniper, great action and a real fun lure to use.
Anything that swims a Manns 1-
Its what I always look for when sorting them out for a day along the river.
- Monts
- Ferox Trout
- Posts: 11312
- Joined: Tue Nov 17 2015 18:52
- Location: Yat Rock
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Steve Le maitre wrote: ↑Thu Jun 13 2019 06:34 -Monts wrote: ↑Wed Jun 12 2019 21:23 -Sorry Jason I can’t comment on any of yours simply because of the sizes ! I know you like your Cranks so they all must be good.Chub Lure A Bomber Square A all day long.
Perch Lure MH Deep Diving Crank "n" Shad in Black Perch.
Perch again Cotton Cordell Grappler Shad in a Crawfish Pattern.
Pike MH Sniper, great action and a real fun lure to use.
Anything that swims a Manns 1-
Its what I always look for when sorting them out for a day along the river.
I know Steve, five of mine measure up to one of yours.
If you wanna go fishing go fishing.- John Gierach
-
- Stickleback
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Sat Nov 25 2017 15:37
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Pike - Mouldy's Hawg Wobbler
Pike - Musky Mania Jake
Chub - Bomber Shallow A
Perch - Salmo Hornet
Perch & Chub - Yogi
Pike - Musky Mania Jake
Chub - Bomber Shallow A
Perch - Salmo Hornet
Perch & Chub - Yogi
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
winniethepooh wrote: ↑Thu Jun 13 2019 08:24 -Hawg Wobbler, get outta here with your topwaters !Pike - Mouldy's Hawg Wobbler
Pike - Musky Mania Jake
Chub - Bomber Shallow A
Perch - Salmo Hornet
Perch & Chub - Yogi
- davelumb
- Forum Sponsor
- Posts: 42603
- Joined: Sat Aug 27 2011 05:00
- Location: On some faraway beach
- Contact:
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
I can't come up with five crankbaits that aren't minnowbaits or flat-sided minnows!
Trolling, the only ones I ended up taking with me were the first three as I always had plenty of Squirrelly Burts with me. :
9" Ernie
Deep Invader
Mann's Magnum Stretch 30+ (or other depth rating depending on venue)
Jointed Grandma
I've used lots of others but they were all much of a muchness.
Casting, prefer twitching minnows like the Bomber really. I can't think of any big pike I've caught casting cranks - although I can remember one which turned away at the edge and another that fell off.
Ernie/Li'l Ernie
Magna Strike Equalizer
Magna Strike Predator
Cordell Big O
Creek Chub Pikie
Trolling, the only ones I ended up taking with me were the first three as I always had plenty of Squirrelly Burts with me. :
9" Ernie
Deep Invader
Mann's Magnum Stretch 30+ (or other depth rating depending on venue)
Jointed Grandma
I've used lots of others but they were all much of a muchness.
Casting, prefer twitching minnows like the Bomber really. I can't think of any big pike I've caught casting cranks - although I can remember one which turned away at the edge and another that fell off.
Ernie/Li'l Ernie
Magna Strike Equalizer
Magna Strike Predator
Cordell Big O
Creek Chub Pikie
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
davelumb wrote: ↑Thu Jun 13 2019 08:43 -Dave I agree, some are Minnows and not technically Cranks, to me if the line tie is on the lip it's a Crank but a list would get very complicated if we did that, just imagine all the categories that we'd have. The jointed Grandma is the best jointed bait of its size - period ! What you doing with that Manns thing, um maybe time to shake the dust off mine.I can't come up with five crankbaits that aren't minnowbaits or flat-sided minnows!
Trolling, the only ones I ended up taking with me were the first three as I always had plenty of Squirrelly Burts with me. :
9" Ernie
Deep Invader
Mann's Magnum Stretch 30+ (or other depth rating depending on venue)
Jointed Grandma
I've used lots of others but they were all much of a muchness.
Casting, prefer twitching minnows like the Bomber really. I can't think of any big pike I've caught casting cranks - although I can remember one which turned away at the edge and another that fell off.
Ernie/Li'l Ernie
Magna Strike Equalizer
Magna Strike Predator
Cordell Big O
Creek Chub Pikie
- davelumb
- Forum Sponsor
- Posts: 42603
- Joined: Sat Aug 27 2011 05:00
- Location: On some faraway beach
- Contact:
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
The Mann's baits get down to where they say they will and have a nice slim profile for (I think) better hooking. Forgot to mention, the 9" Erines are the originals before the 'improved' design with the clear lip.
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
davelumb wrote: ↑Thu Jun 13 2019 09:12 -Shame they changed the lip angle on the Ernie, you’re right you got a better action on the early ones but with their opaque plastic body and lip the fools had no option but to paint the lip as wellThe Mann's baits get down to where they say they will and have a nice slim profile for (I think) better hooking. Forgot to mention, the 9" Erines are the originals before the 'improved' design with the clear lip.
-
- Chub
- Posts: 1253
- Joined: Mon Sep 05 2011 05:00
- Location: Ireland
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Steve Le maitre wrote: ↑Thu Jun 13 2019 06:04 -Very interesting Pat you placed the 8” Hooker on here and rate it so highly, more so is that you have the 8” Jake here ! - the 8” Jake !
Yes the Ernie is unique and pretty much bombproof, it’s also hard to get one snagged up solid - but top 5 ! What special things are you doing with it Pat ?
I still can’t get over the 8” Jake though
Thanks for those Pat, soon when we run out we can do another top 5
ps At the start I did say they could be your favourite and not necessarily “great” catchers so that explains the 8” Jake thing !
[/quote]
Steve ,
the Hooker is up there not for the amount of fish it takes , but its nearly always a good fish when it does catch !
Also on one particular day in winter I whitewashed my boating partne 7-0 with it , which doesn`t happen too often ! 7 doubles including 2 x 20`s ....
8" Jakes , because they will almost always get all sizes of fish , and I`ve had a 20lb pike and a 10lb Ferox on the same day with one .
Also had my lough PB with one .
Surprisingly I cannot get a bite on a DR , whats that about ??? Only ever had one fish (yeah that`s a 1! ) , and that was on a jointed knockoff copy!
But I have had this conversation with various guys over the years and sometimes even waters on the same system have different preferences.
Rgds , Pat
-
- Zander
- Posts: 5602
- Joined: Mon Aug 29 2011 05:00
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
I fished a water for 4 seasons and had only one fish to a DR. Other cranks did very well there, especially the Legend Jnr running at a similar depth. I moved on to the next water down on the system, where the DR accounted for a lot of good fish. I just happily scratched my head.
The 8" Jake is a favourite of mine fished very slow on leadcore when the fish are lying up during a cold front. These days are often 1 fish days, but it's usually a fish worth getting out of bed for. The Legend Sunny is another lure that fishes really well in this manner. Both have very pronounced rolling actions, but with the very slow speed this is reduced and it just seems to work.
Steve... it is the 7" Molly that I use most. Mine are hammered. The action is subtle and it stays stable when fished fast. Fast puts it in front of more fish, and subtle catches clear water pike in all moods.
I'm a fan of the both the early and modified 9" Ernies. I assume the change came about to make them remain stable at the speeds musky anglers troll? The early ones are an a**e to tune as the the window of 'running true' is a very fine one. The modified ones are quicker to tune, and I haven't noticed a difference in catch rate.
Never used a jointed Granny but might give one a whirl now.
Magnum Hellcats are a soft spot of mine. After catching Chico syndrome I appear to have crossed over to the collector dark side.
The 8" Jake is a favourite of mine fished very slow on leadcore when the fish are lying up during a cold front. These days are often 1 fish days, but it's usually a fish worth getting out of bed for. The Legend Sunny is another lure that fishes really well in this manner. Both have very pronounced rolling actions, but with the very slow speed this is reduced and it just seems to work.
Steve... it is the 7" Molly that I use most. Mine are hammered. The action is subtle and it stays stable when fished fast. Fast puts it in front of more fish, and subtle catches clear water pike in all moods.
I'm a fan of the both the early and modified 9" Ernies. I assume the change came about to make them remain stable at the speeds musky anglers troll? The early ones are an a**e to tune as the the window of 'running true' is a very fine one. The modified ones are quicker to tune, and I haven't noticed a difference in catch rate.
Never used a jointed Granny but might give one a whirl now.
Magnum Hellcats are a soft spot of mine. After catching Chico syndrome I appear to have crossed over to the collector dark side.
-
- Zander
- Posts: 5602
- Joined: Mon Aug 29 2011 05:00
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Steve... how does the dive curve of a Triple D compare with a standard Depth Raider? I've never tried a Triple D.
- Richard Grave
- Perch
- Posts: 523
- Joined: Fri Sep 09 2011 05:00
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
1 - rapala SSR
2 - nils master invincible 25 cm
3 - Magna strike predator
4- jointed sallow raider
5 - original Big S (if allowed)
2 - nils master invincible 25 cm
3 - Magna strike predator
4- jointed sallow raider
5 - original Big S (if allowed)
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
andrew_nagel wrote: ↑Thu Jun 13 2019 15:49 -If your tackle allows 18’ - 20’ running depth with a Depth Raider expect 14’ -16’ with the Triple DSteve... how does the dive curve of a Triple D compare with a standard Depth Raider? I've never tried a Triple D.
The Triple D has a very slow rise and has a more parallel action and offers no protection from bottom contact unlike the DR with its nose down attitude.
Very nice action, solid foam and contains no rattles.
-
- Barbel
- Posts: 3279
- Joined: Fri Mar 13 2015 20:28
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Richard Grave wrote: ↑Thu Jun 13 2019 17:28 -I’m sure you’ll get away with the Big S just fine !1 - rapala SSR
2 - nils master invincible 25 cm
3 - Magna strike predator
4- jointed sallow raider
5 - original Big S (if allowed)
- Richard Grave
- Perch
- Posts: 523
- Joined: Fri Sep 09 2011 05:00
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Amazed no one else has mentioned SSR absolute pike magnets, one of the only cranks I regularly consider throwing instead of a jerkbait or SP.
-
- Zander
- Posts: 5602
- Joined: Mon Aug 29 2011 05:00
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Richard Grave wrote: ↑Thu Jun 13 2019 18:29 -Cracking lure Richard, but they need a coat of epoxy or they get chewed up quickly.Amazed no one else has mentioned SSR absolute pike magnets, one of the only cranks I regularly consider throwing instead of a jerkbait or SP.
-
- Zander
- Posts: 5602
- Joined: Mon Aug 29 2011 05:00
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
Steve Le maitre wrote: ↑Thu Jun 13 2019 18:18 -I'll find one and give it a whirl - thanks. I have a few depth raiders without rattles. They were a Musky Shop 'exclusive' way back.andrew_nagel wrote: ↑Thu Jun 13 2019 15:49 -If your tackle allows 18’ - 20’ running depth with a Depth Raider expect 14’ -16’ with the Triple DSteve... how does the dive curve of a Triple D compare with a standard Depth Raider? I've never tried a Triple D.
The Triple D has a very slow rise and has a more parallel action and offers no protection from bottom contact unlike the DR with its nose down attitude.
Very nice action, solid foam and contains no rattles.
-
- Chub
- Posts: 1985
- Joined: Sat Jan 11 2014 21:49
Re: Your top 5 Cranks
-Depth Raider
-Super Shad Rap
-Squirrelly Jake (ok a Hybrid, but still a crank in my book)
-Ernie/Lil Ernie
-A small crankbait that was in the fox predator range I can’t remember what it was called and the writings well gone as it’s so chewed! I think maybe called warrior? One of my banker lures believe it or not! Think it’s the Extreme body roll on pause that does it but I can’t remember if it did this before I took the original hooks off.
There’s some lures in this thread in my collection that I’m going to have to get wet more often!
-Super Shad Rap
-Squirrelly Jake (ok a Hybrid, but still a crank in my book)
-Ernie/Lil Ernie
-A small crankbait that was in the fox predator range I can’t remember what it was called and the writings well gone as it’s so chewed! I think maybe called warrior? One of my banker lures believe it or not! Think it’s the Extreme body roll on pause that does it but I can’t remember if it did this before I took the original hooks off.
There’s some lures in this thread in my collection that I’m going to have to get wet more often!