Retaining tube/net

Need a recommendation or advice on fishing tackle? Ask in here
Post Reply
User avatar
The predator
General
General
Posts: 11887
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
Location: In toxicated

Retaining tube/net

Post by The predator » Fri May 18 2018 09:56

Found a Fox pike retaining tube when having a clearout. now I've never used this or any other because I heard that some anglers have had fish die in them.
Do any of you guys use them and have you had any bad experiences with them? :shrug:
Incumbam, et sternebant

stuartmason
Sergeant
Sergeant
Posts: 127
Joined: Sun Apr 05 2015 21:05

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by stuartmason » Fri May 18 2018 12:52

I use one never had any probs only retained fish for short time tho

User avatar
Andrew Croft
Bailiff
Bailiff
Posts: 11302
Joined: Wed Nov 02 2011 05:00
Location: Glasgow, Scotland
Contact:

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by Andrew Croft » Fri May 18 2018 13:14

The discussions popped up a few times. iirc, general consensus is very short periods if it will benefit the pike.

Imo for anything other than trying to help a weary pike etc is a total no no.

I hate when people use em to keep a pike caught at night until morning just for a photograph in daylight.

If they're dieing its probably been left in a mucky margin for hours on end. shame on people who will be doing it in this weather :no:
Let me ask you one question. Is your money that good. Will it buy you forgiveness. Do you think that it could. I think you will find When your death takes its toll All the money you made Will never buy back your soul.

User avatar
The predator
General
General
Posts: 11887
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
Location: In toxicated

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by The predator » Fri May 18 2018 13:16

Yeah but I've heard of anglers sacking up while they phone a friend which could possibly be a bit of a wait
Incumbam, et sternebant

User avatar
Andrew Croft
Bailiff
Bailiff
Posts: 11302
Joined: Wed Nov 02 2011 05:00
Location: Glasgow, Scotland
Contact:

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by Andrew Croft » Fri May 18 2018 13:19

Why ? No camera/scales ?
Let me ask you one question. Is your money that good. Will it buy you forgiveness. Do you think that it could. I think you will find When your death takes its toll All the money you made Will never buy back your soul.

User avatar
The predator
General
General
Posts: 11887
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00
Location: In toxicated

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by The predator » Fri May 18 2018 14:43

Andrew Croft wrote:
Why ? No camera/scales ?
Some people just don't think
Incumbam, et sternebant

User avatar
Jimk2
Colonel
Colonel
Posts: 3588
Joined: Fri Sep 09 2011 05:00
Location: Sunderland
Contact:

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by Jimk2 » Fri May 18 2018 15:52

I have the ET one, had it for years and never used it.

philbrown
Captain
Captain
Posts: 656
Joined: Sun Aug 28 2011 05:00

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by philbrown » Fri May 18 2018 16:01

Never had a problem on the few occasions I've used them. The pike remain pretty calm in the tube but come out with a new lease of life which can make for an interesting photo!

martin(rockape)
Captain
Captain
Posts: 606
Joined: Fri Nov 14 2014 22:11
Location: Northamptonshire

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by martin(rockape) » Fri May 18 2018 19:32

Did have a pike/carp sack, never used it and thinking about it its probably a bad thing to use as the sack itself would no doubt smother the fish restricting flow to the gills. Like i said never used it and has been binned..

Regards

Martin

User avatar
andypee
Lieutenant
Lieutenant
Posts: 497
Joined: Tue Feb 02 2016 08:34
Location: East yorkshire

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by andypee » Sun May 20 2018 16:33

I've just purchased the chub extra protection retaining sling, got to say it's massive but light, I thought it may be best to rest a fish while sorting camera out etc.

I would only use it if I felt needed but at least I'm prepared now :shrug:

Andy.

zodiac
Major
Major
Posts: 1262
Joined: Sat Oct 22 2011 05:00
Location: central jockland

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by zodiac » Sun May 20 2018 20:07

Used a retaining tube a few times over the years, I always take one with me it's only been used a handful of times. I recall one occasion, I had an 18 something ounces, near dusk. It had a massive coil of mono and wire, with a few hooks tangled up, at the back of it's throat. It didn't take too long to untangle the mess and remove my own hooks, plus the hooks that were already there, but a bit longer than usual. Got it the water asap, it was just lying on it's side, I sat there, keeping it upright, moving it back and forward slowly, trying to get some water flowing through it's gills , for over half an hour. It was still alive, but if I let it go it bellied up.. hands freezing, after a while I put it in the tube, propped it up with banksticks, got to my bed. First light, up and checked how she was, it was kicking and thrashing. There's no doubt in my mind using the tube saved that fishes life. That alone is enough to make me take it every time whether I use it or not.
'Politicians. Don't vote, it just encourages them. The desire to be a politician should bar you from life from ever being one' Billy Connoly

martin(rockape)
Captain
Captain
Posts: 606
Joined: Fri Nov 14 2014 22:11
Location: Northamptonshire

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by martin(rockape) » Sun May 20 2018 21:05

zodiac wrote:
Used a retaining tube a few times over the years, I always take one with me it's only been used a handful of times. I recall one occasion, I had an 18 something ounces, near dusk. It had a massive coil of mono and wire, with a few hooks tangled up, at the back of it's throat. It didn't take too long to untangle the mess and remove my own hooks, plus the hooks that were already there, but a bit longer than usual. Got it the water asap, it was just lying on it's side, I sat there, keeping it upright, moving it back and forward slowly, trying to get some water flowing through it's gills , for over half an hour. It was still alive, but if I let it go it bellied up.. hands freezing, after a while I put it in the tube, propped it up with banksticks, got to my bed. First light, up and checked how she was, it was kicking and thrashing. There's no doubt in my mind using the tube saved that fishes life. That alone is enough to make me take it every time whether I use it or not.

I hope she rewards you with some good sport from her off spring in the future if she hasn't done so already.

Regards

Martin

Kevin O'Keeffe
Charity Fundraiser
Charity Fundraiser
Posts: 2568
Joined: Sat Aug 27 2011 05:00

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by Kevin O'Keeffe » Mon May 21 2018 14:55

Always got one in the bag / by the mat in case something goes wrong. used it occasionally. camera batt failure was one time that comes to mind. I have had em jump out of a landing net and don't see much difference between leaving them in a net or in a properly staked tube tbh. Doubles up as a livo store sometimes if I catch some.
Love the hit!

John O Grady
Captain
Captain
Posts: 617
Joined: Fri Jan 20 2012 06:00
Location: Cavan Ireland

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by John O Grady » Mon May 21 2018 18:17

I use a big Korum sling to hold the fish while i get everything set up regularly, as long as your sensible about it i dont think you'll have many issues. Just avoid doing it for too long, get the fish into a reasonable depth if possible and make sure the fish isn't tangled.

User avatar
Andrew Croft
Bailiff
Bailiff
Posts: 11302
Joined: Wed Nov 02 2011 05:00
Location: Glasgow, Scotland
Contact:

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by Andrew Croft » Mon May 21 2018 18:23

zodiac wrote:
Used a retaining tube a few times over the years, I always take one with me it's only been used a handful of times. I recall one occasion, I had an 18 something ounces, near dusk. It had a massive coil of mono and wire, with a few hooks tangled up, at the back of it's throat. It didn't take too long to untangle the mess and remove my own hooks, plus the hooks that were already there, but a bit longer than usual. Got it the water asap, it was just lying on it's side, I sat there, keeping it upright, moving it back and forward slowly, trying to get some water flowing through it's gills , for over half an hour. It was still alive, but if I let it go it bellied up.. hands freezing, after a while I put it in the tube, propped it up with banksticks, got to my bed. First light, up and checked how she was, it was kicking and thrashing. There's no doubt in my mind using the tube saved that fishes life. That alone is enough to make me take it every time whether I use it or not.
Thats the game mate. Thats how they should be used :thumbs:
Let me ask you one question. Is your money that good. Will it buy you forgiveness. Do you think that it could. I think you will find When your death takes its toll All the money you made Will never buy back your soul.

User avatar
MarkBerrisford
Major
Major
Posts: 1151
Joined: Fri Sep 02 2011 05:00
Location: Manchester

Re: Retaining tube/net

Post by MarkBerrisford » Mon May 21 2018 18:27

I bought one of the floating weigh slings for if I need to hold a fish when I’m on my own, only needed it a few times but it does the job
Search MB Custom Lures on Facebook

Post Reply